
Hiring a contractor
How to compare renovation quotes
Compare renovation quotes only after every contractor has priced the same written scope, then line them up item by item instead of by total. Check what each includes, which costs are allowances, what is excluded or left to you, whether HST is in the price, and the payment terms. In Ontario, an estimate that forms part of your contract cannot be exceeded by more than 10% unless you agree to new or different work, so the detail in each estimate matters.
Fix the scope before you compare a single number
Quotes differ most when contractors are pricing different jobs. Give every firm the same written scope, the same drawings if you have them, and the same finish level for cabinets, counters, tile and fixtures. Ontario's consumer protection guidance adds two conditions: get at least three written estimates, and never accept one given over the phone or without the contractor inspecting the space.
Ask each firm to price in the same order: design and permits, demolition, rough-in work, finishes, then extras. If someone sends a single lump sum, ask for it broken into lines. What a renovation estimate includes lists the lines a complete one carries.
Line up the quotes item by item
Copy each quote into one grid, a row per line item and a column per contractor. Gaps jump out when a line appears in two quotes and not the third.
| Line item | A complete quote states | Common gap |
|---|---|---|
| Design and drawings | Who prepares them and whether permit drawings are included | Drawings billed separately later |
| Permits and inspections | Who applies, and whether City fees are in the price | Permit quietly left to the homeowner |
| Demolition and disposal | Removal, bin or haul-away, and protection of the rest of the house | Disposal listed as an extra |
| Plumbing | Which fixtures move, new shut-offs, drains and venting | Priced as if fixtures stay put when your plan moves them |
| Electrical | New circuits, lighting, the licensed electrical contractor and ESA notification | Dedicated appliance or heated-floor circuits missing |
| Walls, floors and ceilings | Drywall, patching, levelling, waterproofing in wet areas | Patching outside the work area excluded |
| Cabinets, vanity and counters | A specified product or an allowance, plus installation and templating | An allowance too low to buy what you showed them |
| Tile | Material allowance per square foot, with labour priced separately | Labour for herringbone or large-format tile not included |
| Painting and trim | Which rooms and surfaces are painted | Paint marked 'by owner' |
| Cleanup and tax | Final clean, and the total with 13% HST shown | Tax added at the end |
Read allowances, exclusions and 'by owner' items closely
An allowance is a placeholder for something you have not chosen yet, such as tile at a set price per square foot or a budget for the faucet. If your choice costs more, you pay the difference; if it costs less, you should receive a credit. Low allowances are the easiest way for a quote to look cheaper than it is, so compare each one with prices from the showrooms you plan to visit.
Exclusions are the other half. Look for 'by owner', 'not included', 'if required' and 'TBD'. Electrical panel upgrades, structural repairs, hazardous material testing in older homes, appliance installation and painting are frequent candidates. If two firms exclude something and the third includes it, the third may be the only quote describing your real job. Older Toronto houses deserve extra attention: see asbestos and lead in older homes before you renovate.
Know what Ontario's 10% estimate rule covers
The Consumer Protection Act, 2002 gives estimates real weight, but only when they are part of the agreement. Section 10 says that if a consumer agreement includes an estimate, the supplier cannot charge more than 10% above it; if it does, you can require the work at the estimated price. The same section lets both sides amend the price when you ask for additional or different goods or services.
So ask that the estimate be attached to the contract, record every change you request as a signed amendment with its own price, and prefer detailed estimates: the vaguer the lines, the harder it is to show what the original price included. The pricing method matters too.
| Pricing type | How the final bill is set | Watch for |
|---|---|---|
| Fixed price | The contract price, plus or minus signed changes | Exclusions that return as extras |
| Estimate in the contract | No more than 10% over the estimate under the CPA, unless you agree to new or different work | Vague lines that make the scope arguable |
| Cost-plus or time and materials | Actual costs plus an agreed fee or markup | No ceiling unless you negotiate one, so ask for a maximum and regular cost reports |
Compare the terms as closely as the totals
Two quotes with the same total can carry very different risk. Put these terms in your grid as well.
- Deposit: Ontario's consumer protection office recommends no more than 10% down.
- Payment schedule: tied to milestones you can see, such as rough-in inspections or cabinet installation, rather than calendar dates.
- Holdback: the contractor should expect you to retain 10% of each payment under the Construction Act. See holdbacks on renovation projects in Ontario.
- Schedule: a start date, an estimated duration and what happens if the start slips.
- Changes: how extras are priced, and any markup on them.
- Warranty: length, start date and coverage, in writing.
When the lowest quote is the right one, and when it isn't
After you equalize scope, totals may still differ, and that alone is not a warning. Firms carry different overheads, crew structures and levels of supervision. The question is whether you can see what the lower number buys. Ask each contractor to explain the gap in writing: which lines, which materials, how many site visits, who manages the trades.
If one quote remains far below the others with the same scope, it may rest on cheaper materials, fewer supervision hours or exclusions you have not spotted yet. Clarify the scope, ask for revised quotes, and then decide on value. For typical cost ranges to sanity-check the numbers, see kitchen renovation cost in Toronto.
Questions
Should a renovation quote include HST?
Ask, because quotes differ. Renovation work in Ontario carries 13% HST, and a quote shown before tax will look lower than one shown with it. Compare every quote on the same basis; HST on renovations in Ontario explains the tax.
Is it fair to tell one contractor what another quoted?
You can, but sharing the scope difference is more useful than sharing the price. Tell a contractor that another firm included a line they left out, and ask them to price it. That makes the comparison fairer without turning it into a bidding war.
Why are renovation quotes so far apart?
Usually because each firm priced a slightly different job: different allowances, exclusions, finish levels or assumptions about what is behind the walls. Overhead and supervision also vary. Equalize the scope and the remaining spread is usually easier to explain.
How long does a renovation quote stay valid?
That depends on the contractor, and the quote should say so. Material prices and crew schedules change, so check the date on each quote and confirm it is still valid before you sign.
Sources and further reading
- Your rights when starting home renovations or repairs, Government of Ontario
- Consumer Protection Act, 2002, section 10 (estimates)
- Construction Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. C.30
Checked November 19, 2026. Codes, by-laws, prices and product specifications change; confirm with your municipality, condo corporation or supplier before you build.
Keep reading
Related guides




