Renovations

Guides

Recessed black shower niche holding black dispensers in white marble-look porcelain walls

Hiring a contractor

How to read contractor reviews

Read contractor reviews for patterns instead of the star average. Look at reviews spread over several years, read the 2, 3 and 4-star ones, and check whether reviewers describe projects like yours, how problems were handled and what happened after completion. Be wary of sudden spikes, repeated wording and reviewers with no history, which Canada's Competition Bureau flags as signs of fake reviews, then confirm what you read by calling references.

By the Purple Kitchen & Bath team · Updated · 4 min read · Photo: a Purple Properties project

Read the pattern, not the average

A 4.8 average tells you less than the shape of the record behind it. Sort by newest, then scroll back several years. The Competition Bureau's advice on fake reviews starts here: look at reviews over a long period, and watch for a sudden spike in very positive reviews or a sudden dip into very bad ones.

Then read the middle. The Bureau suggests reading the 2, 3 and 4-star reviews as well, because they tend to describe trade-offs. For a renovation, the useful trade-offs are about schedule, communication, dust and cleanup, how surprises behind the walls were priced, and whether the crew came back for the deficiency list.

Review signals and how to check them
SignalWhat it may meanHow to check
A burst of 5-star reviews within a few weeksA review push, or simply a run of finished projectsOpen reviewer profiles and look at the projects described
Reviewers with new profiles who only post praiseThe Bureau flags recently created profiles as a warning signCheck what else each reviewer has written
Several reviews using the same phrasesThe Bureau flags repeated language across reviewersRead those reviews side by side
Nothing but 5-star reviewsThe Bureau calls a record of only 5-star reviews a red flagLook for other sources and call references
Detailed reviews naming the rooms, scope and staffConcrete claims you can verifyAsk the contractor about that project
Several complaints about the same issueA recurring problem, such as missed days or slow callbacksAsk the contractor what changed since

What a useful renovation review contains

The best reviews read like a short project report. Give more weight to reviews that include:

  • The room and scope: 'ensuite with a curbless shower and heated floor' tells you more than 'great job'.
  • The timeline against the plan, and the reason for any delay.
  • How changes and hidden problems were priced and approved.
  • Who the homeowner dealt with day to day.
  • Permits and inspections, if the job needed them.
  • What happened after completion: deficiencies, warranty calls, how fast someone returned.
  • A date months after the job finished, which shows how the work is holding up.

How the platforms and the law police reviews

Google's Maps content policy prohibits reviews that are paid for, directly or in kind, and bars businesses from offering discounts, free services or money in exchange for a review, a revision or the removal of a negative one. It also treats reviews from people with a conflict of interest, such as current or former employees, as a violation, and forbids businesses from selectively asking only happy customers. A business may still ask customers for reviews, as long as it offers nothing in return. HomeStars, a Canadian review site for home improvement pros, runs its own moderation of homeowner reviews.

The law adds weight. The Competition Bureau has warned that the deceptive marketing provisions of the Competition Act apply to anyone who writes or permits reviews that give a false or misleading impression, and that employees must disclose their connection to a business even when their opinion is honest. If you believe you have found fake reviews, you can report them to the Bureau. None of this makes a platform's record perfect, so read critically either way.

Platform awards come from the platform's own data and rules. HomeStars' Best of the Best, for example, goes to pros that have won its annual Best of Award three or more years in a row. Treat an award as evidence of a consistent review record, not as an inspection of the work.

How to weigh complaints and the contractor's replies

One poor review in a long record is normal for a firm that finishes many projects; the same complaint repeated across years is not. Separate what was outside the contractor's control, such as a back-ordered faucet or a permit queue, from what was within it, such as missed days, unreturned calls or disputes over deposits.

Then read the reply. A good response is specific, calm, explains what was done and keeps the homeowner's private details out of public view. A defensive reply, or none at all to a serious complaint, tells you how a disagreement on your own job might go. Reviews written mid-project mostly describe communication; reviews written after completion describe the result.

Turn reviews into reference checks

Reviews are one input. The Bureau suggests asking people you trust and asking the company for references, and Ontario's consumer guidance recommends at least three references from homeowners who had similar work done, some recent and some further back. Useful questions for a reference:

  • Was the final price close to the contract, and how were changes handled?
  • Did the job finish near the planned date?
  • How were problems found behind the walls dealt with?
  • Has anything needed fixing since, and how quickly did they return?
  • Would you hire them again for the same kind of work?

Questions

Are Google reviews or HomeStars reviews more reliable?

Neither is a guarantee. Both platforms have rules against fake and incentivized reviews, and both can miss things. Read both, check that the picture is consistent across them, and use references to fill the gaps.

How many reviews should a renovation contractor have?

There is no magic number. A renovation firm completes far fewer jobs in a year than a restaurant serves customers in a week, so a modest count spread over many years can say more than a large number posted recently. Look at the spread over time.

Can a contractor have bad reviews removed?

A business can report a review it believes breaks a platform's rules, and the platform decides. Google's policy bars businesses from offering money, discounts or free services to have a negative review revised or removed.

Should I trust reviews that mention staff by name?

Names make a review easier to verify, which is useful. Ask the contractor about the project described. If a reviewer turns out to work for the business, the Competition Bureau's position is that the connection should have been disclosed.

Sources and further reading

  1. Five-star fake out: how to spot fake online reviews, Competition Bureau Canada
  2. Online reviews posted by employees: businesses could be liable, Competition Bureau Canada
  3. Prohibited and restricted content (fake engagement, rating manipulation), Maps user-generated content policy, Google
  4. Your rights when starting home renovations or repairs (checking references), Government of Ontario

Checked November 19, 2026. Codes, by-laws, prices and product specifications change; confirm with your municipality, condo corporation or supplier before you build.

Plan your kitchen renovation

Initial consultations are complimentary. Jordan Duda, our client care and lead estimator, is usually your first point of contact.